如果您閱讀此郵件有困難﹐請訪問 http://www.cmcmembers.com.au/traders_review/tc/200609/20060920_tradereview_tc.html

CFD Trader Review - September 2006

<< click on a headline to go directly to the article >><< print this issue >>

   
   
 
  lead story >> to bid or not to bid  
 



.

 

 

One of the most often quoted sayings in the markets is to ‘buy on rumour and sell on fact’. And for the past 12 months Australians seem to be heeding this in the midst of what seems to be a renewed level of mergers and acquisitions and takeover activities in the local market.

It was almost a year ago when Toll Holdings, Australia’s largest transport group, launched a takeover bid on Patrick Corporation, then one of the major port operators in the country. This deal, which was completed in May 2006 definitely ranks among the most bitterly fought and protracted takeover battles in Australia.

 
  1
<< top
next>>  
  lead story >> to bid or not to bid  

 

 

From almost every angle the Toll takeover bid had the hallmark of a bloody corporate battle, which may be interesting to watch from the sidelines, but not when you’re caught in the middle of the crossfire.

According to industry analysts and observers, Toll’s long-drawn-out bid and eventual takeover of Patrick may be seen as one of the best deals in corporate Australia. This is because all things considered the deal generated a certain level of volatility and market activity during the entire length of the deal. And when it was finally in the bag, Toll’s share price has started to consolidate and settle near where it started before it launched the takeover.

“It (Toll takeover) was one of the best examples of a big company taking on another company –a strategic move that will deliver long-term benefits to investors,” said Greg Canavan, senior securities analyst at Fat Prophets.

Damian Isbister, investment manager at Cube Financial agrees with Canavan when he said, “The Toll takeover must be one of the favourites given all the twists and turns along the way. It should be noted though that the proof is in the pudding. Since the acquisition TOL’s share price has gone for strength to strength as the company extracts value from its new assets. The company has managed to maintain remarkable earnings per share growth of around 15%.”


 


Most recently, after the dust in the Toll takeover has settled another flurry of takeovers and mergers & acquisitions has set in. For the past few weeks the level of takeover activities seems to be at record high for this time of the year. Some of the big names and high profile takeovers and mergers (some have just been sealed and others are still unfolding as we go to press) of late include: Coles, which is rumoured to be targeted by a consortium of private equity companies; OAMPS which received a friendly offer from Wesfarmers; MFS bid for S8 to create a major player in the holiday accommodation industry in Australasia; the AGL- Alinta merger; the OneSteel and Smorgon Steel merger; Allco Equity’s failed bid for Baycorp and Wattyl.

While there’s no question that mergers and acquisitions tend to generate more activity and a certain level o fvolatility in the markets, the question to be asked is how do these corporate fights

 


affect traders and investors. We asked several industry analysts and observers about their view and opinion.

Trade Review (TR): What’s the impact of mergers and acquisitions/takeovers in the overall market or in the companies involved?

Hamish McCathie (HM): Director, CFD Trading Pty Ltd:

“The slightest hint of a takeover or merger is more than enough to give share prices a boost both in terms of the level of activity and sometimes volatility. This is obviously the case with Coles share price which has been trading around the $13.80 - $14.00 level since the word of a possible approach from potential buyers came out a few weeks ago.”


 
  2
<< top
next>>  
  lead story >> to bid or not to bid  

 

 


Greg Canavan (GC): Senior equities analyst, Fat Prophets:
“Takeover bids/mergers and acquisitions tend to push the price of the target company significantly higher while the buyer may be pushed lower at times. Price movements during takeover bids are usually short-term. Once the deal is done the share price usually moves back to a reasonable level.”

Damian Isbister (DI): Investment manager, Cube Financial:
“Generally the company that is being taken over has a substantial increase in its share price, even a rumour can drive the stock up. On the other hand unless there are some very clear synergies to be created by the merger the company mounting the takeover will generally remain constant or even fall in value.”

TR: Are there trading opportunities around mergers and acquisitions/takeovers?

HM: “Usually people trade the target company’s shares but not the buyer company. In many cases there are a lot of uncertainties around the buyer, for example, if there is another bidder that will come into the picture that may push the price even higher and may cause the bid to fail.”

GC: “In some cases there may be trading opportunities around takeover bids. However, we advocate long-term investing instead of short-term opportunistic trading.”

 


DI: “There are trading opportunities around mergers and takeover bids. However, a lot depends on how the deal is structured and the type of strategies deployed. If there are two companies bidding for a company this could be the start of a ‘bidding war’ the best case for a target company’s shareholders at this point you would be purchasing shares in the target company.

The other opportunity that would exist is if the buyer was to offer stock to the target in this case you maybe able to identify an opportunity to go long and actually short the acquirer. This strategy really pays off when the acquirer has to offer additional cash incentive to sweeten the deal for the target company’s shareholders to encourage them to accept the deal.”

TR: What do traders and investors have to look out for if they want to get a piece of the action during


 


takeover or mergers and acquisitions?

GC: “You have to do your homework and make sure there will be no opposition to the takeover. An example of this was the takeover bid for Adsteam from a Danish shipping company. At some stage the bidder was confident that the deal would be approved, but then the competition regulators turned around and this has affected the Adsteam share price. You have to do your research and study the sectors or companies involved to find out if there will be potential oppositions or hurdles.”

DI: “Investors should lookout for a potential “bidding war” where two buyers have the same target as this could lead to a higher price being paid, or alternatively if there is one buyer try and determine what they can afford to pay and what the acceptance of the current shareholders is, if low buy in.”

 

 
  3
<< top
next>>  

  guru profile >> richard farleigh  


 

Despite what was described as a ‘difficult childhood’, Richard Farleigh said he did not set out to become a multi-millionaire. There was no epiphany or a ‘eureka!’ moment that gave him any sign of what his future would be.

“In fact, I believe I’m a good example of how people can stumble into things,” he said in a self-deprecating manner.

Eureka or no eureka, one thing Richard said he had when he was growing up was motivation. And plenty of it.

“I was very motivated at each stage of my life even when I was in school and was I was just starting to work. I believe that if you do something well and you give your best at every task you have you will soon reap the rewards,” he said.

While not denying nor glorifying the impact of his childhood, Richard said the experience, which made him feel like an outsider also made him a strong willed person.

   
  4
<< top
next>>  
  guru profile >> richard farleigh  

 

 

 

“In a way my experience and the circumstances when I was young forced me to make up my own mind. I had no role model to look up to and it made me think for myself. At the same time, I felt like I didn’t have anything or anyone to fall back on, which gave me the extra motivation to work hard and to achieve.”

Today, Richard, who has joined the ranks of the BRW Top 200 richest Australians, is definitely enjoying the rewards of his years of hard work. Far from the old truck and tents where he used to live with his other siblings more than 40 years ago, Richard is now at home in Monaco and London where he spends most of his time with his wife and three kids.

In between his difficult childhood and on his way to Monaco Richard managed to study economics at the University of New South Wales. With a generous scholarship from the Reserve Bank of Australia, Richard graduated with first class honours that would prove a turning point in his life.

Armed with his outstanding academic credentials, he joined Bankers Trust Australia’s derivatives trading desk where he would end up being one of the biggest single money earners.

Richard’s exceptional performance at Bankers Trust Australia proved to be his ticket to yet another stage of his lucrative career in the financial markets

 



. In 1993 he joined a Bermuda-based international hedge fund where he honed his trading skills and put his own developed trading systems to ultimate use.

From Bermuda Richard looked to other international markets and opportunities that would not limit him on the trading floor. He started trading currencies, treasury and would later on invest his personal money on start up companies.

At last count Richard must have backed over 50 start-up companies, including some technology firms on the lead up to the tech boom in the early 2000. Some of the companies he backed went bust when the tech bubble eventually burst.

However, his early wins and profitable investment put him in good stead.

Despite his investments in various start up companies and other ventures, Richard said he is not a tough businessman, at least not in the sense the word tough is being flaunted in the business or corporate world.

“It is a tough environment out there because there are far less opportunities or valuable investment vehicles to find. But that doesn’t mean you have to be tough or be unscrupulous in doing business,” Richard said.

 


 

 

He said he’s happy that despite his investment in various companies (at last count it shows that he must have invested in at least 50 start up and other fledgling companies in the past 10 years) he hasn’t made any enemies. This he said is quite an enviable track record in the business world.

Though these may all sound too good to be true, Richard admitted that the road to his success has not always been smooth. He had his share of rough patches and bumps along the way. In his book “Taming the Lion”, he shared some of his trading and investment strategies.


 
  5
<< top
next>>  
  guru profile >> richard farleigh  

 

 

 

When it comes to trading, Richard believes that good trading ideas are based on observations of market behaviour.

“I believe markets behave in certain ways and by observing these market behaviour people should find a way of trading the markets. I believe good trading ideas are based on observations, not on reams and reams of data,” Richard said

In his book, Richard set out an ambitious task for himself to come up with 100 trading and investment strategies that worked for him over the years.

“I believe there is a gap in the market for good investment books with real and applicable strategies. In my book, I tried to focus on my mistakes and how I learned from them so that people would realize the challenges of investing and dealing with the markets,” Richard said.

Here’s a snapshot of Richard’s thoughts on the various aspects of trading, investment and the financial markets in general.

 

 

 


Though quick to admit that small companies may have a higher failure rate compared to their giant counterparts, Richard believes that small companies offer the best risk-reward particularly if combined with diversification.


 


As an ‘angel investor’ to start up companies, Richard had invested in various ventures including several technology companies, diamond mine, private member’s club, sporting goods retailer and corporate advisory business. So far, he had 26 wins and 26 losses in his venture capital investment.

 
  6
<< top
next>>  
  what's new at cmc markets >>  
 



.In the beginning there were only 200. Then there were 300. Today, there are more than 500 Australian share CFDs that you can trade with CMC Markets.

Effective 6 September the list of tradeable Australian share CFDs with CMC Markets has been expanded to the top 500 listed shares. The number one CFD provider in Australia said the move to expand the list came in response to traders’ demand for more CFDs.

“We have seen how Australian investors and traders have come to fully embrace CFDs after a few years of being available here in the country. With this open mindedness and acceptance came the demand for more CFDs to be traded,” said David Trew, managing director of CMC Markets Asia Pacific.

He said CMC Markets will continue to expand its product offering not only in Australian share CFDs but also international sectors and indice

 



Aside from the top 500 Australian share CFDs, CMC Markets is also adding nine new international indices including H Share China Index, Korea, Singapore, Taiwan, Tokyo, Norwegian, Swedish, German Midcap and German Tech indices. For a full list of the additional international indices, please click here. .

CMC Markets is also expanding its international share CFD offerings by adding new share CFDs from New Zealand, Singapore, Japan, Austria, Spain and Portugal. So whether you want to trade the Australian, Asian or the European markets all you have to do is trade them from one single account with CMC Markets which gives you access to all of these international markets.

For a full list of the ASX and international share CFDs available to trade with CMC Markets – including the margin rate and information on shorting for each Share CFD - please click here.

 
  7
<< top
next>>  
  CMC Markets Education >>  

 
  8
<< top
next>>  
  trainers corner >> peter mathers  


 

It’s been almost a year now since I’ve taken a more ‘formal’ role as a trading educator and coach to CFD traders. One of the interesting things I’ve noted is that as more and more people become aware of CFDs and as this product ‘matures’ over the past few years, traders are also getting more adept and sophisticated in their trading strategies.

For the past few months I’ve been receiving a lot of questions and enquiries about Elliott Wave Theory and how it can be applied in analysing or understanding the markets.

What I’ve also noticed is the proliferation of Elliott Wave software and tools now available out there. This is great because it brings the new trader closer to understanding the behaviour of a market, as each market has its own personality and finger print which needs to be discovered.

The major Elliott Wave programs are Advance Get, Elwave and Profit Source, there are also others like EWA and plug-ins which are in my opinion are best left alone.

Even the best Elliott Wave technicians get the wrong wave count a lot.

 
  9
<< top
next>>  
  trainers corner >> peter mathers  

 

 


It’s not until after the structure is complete do we understand it. As Elliott Wave technicians we are trying to preempt the unfolding wave structure.

Even when Robert Prechter, considered one of the Elliott Wave gurus, won the US trading competition with 444% profit, half of his trades were incorrect. But because there are only three rules with Elliott Wave you will know when you are wrong and if you have a clear exit strategy, along with good money management, it can become one of the greatest trading tools.

With Elliott Wave there are a good dozen degrees, that is, cycles within cycles (you can email me for these) and as a professional Elliott analyst you need to be able to label these cycles of degrees as they will let you know where the market is at any time.

The Advance Get operates on three levels. It doesn’t label them with the official Elliott labeling. Profit Source is a little like Advance Get but much more user friendly. Both Advance Get and Profit Source are designed for particular strategies such as the Wave 4 Buy. This strategy has a reasonable outcome because these software programs find a higher probability in identifying the later part of the wave count once wave one, two and three are in place. So along with good money management and using the three Elliott rules (see Trade Review June 06) you have a practical trading method.

 


As we know not all things are perfect, so we need to identify the weaknesses and strengths in all trading tools we use. Understanding these subtleties can make the difference between receiving income or incurring an expense.

Let’s take a look at a few aspects, first, the Wave Four Buy in Advance Get or Profit Source. The first thing to understand with Elliott Wave is that there are eleven different types of corrections, this is the difficult part of using Elliott, because a correction could be any one of these types of corrections.

The good news is there are also ‘guidelines’ that are helpful to use when applying Elliott Wave. One of these is the guideline on ‘Alternation’, that is, if wave two is simple then we can expect wave four to be complex, also if wave two is sharp we can expect wave four to be sideways.

Understanding the internal structures of corrections is also very helpful in understanding what type of correction the market is in. For example, Expanding Flat, Regular Flat, Running Flat or a Zigzag, Triangle or a combination of all of these patterns.

Essentially because wave four is normally the complicated correction and the most difficult to navigate through, as a guideline wave four normally retraces 38.2% the distance of wave three, or for a more accurate indication wave four retraces to wave four of one lesser degree.


 


A few ways to strengthen the wave four buy is to use the Trading Levels which I wrote about in an earlier article (Feb 06 Trade Review), that is buying above a Trading Level, eg buying above a market constructional support level.

In summing up the range of Elliott software, the Profit Source software seems much more user friendly and the cost is lower, they are a great way to learn the Elliott Wave theory.

The CMC 2 Day Pro CFD course looks at how to further strengthen these Elliott Wave entries and offers a more detailed look into Elliott Wave Analysis. Contact Bradley Field at CMC b.field@cmcmarkets.com for course details.

Also as mentioned last month we have developed an Excel spreadsheet for CMC Markets share CFDs that updates every 15 minutes. It includes risk management, portfolio, multiple R, expectancy and a trade plan. This is a free product and it is for educational purposes only. For a free copy email info@ka-ching.com.au

.



 
  10
<< top
next>>  
  frader in action >> reynaldo  
  11
<< top
next>>  
  frader in action >> reynaldo  


 

 

While a strong advocate of systems trading, Reynaldo said trading is not all about systems. It is about you and your psychology. He’s got his own personal experience and ‘evolution’ as a trader to prove his point.

It was early 2001 when Reynaldo was first introduced to trading when a friend of his invited him to attend a seminar about share trading. He got interested with what he heard and after several other seminars he was convinced that there is something in trading.

“I’m a logical thinker and I have some background in computers being a database administrator before, so most of the things I heard from the seminars made sense to me. I pursued systems development and technical analysis for almost a year until I have a system that I’m comfortable with,” Reynaldo recalled.

 

In 2003, after he’s been trading profitably using his system, Reynaldo was hit by one of the major setbacks in his trading career. He was long gold and the price of gold was falling fast. When he closed his gold position he almost lost his bank account.

But this setback would prove to be a turning point in Reynaldo’s trading career. “At that time I thought: I have two choices. I can either go back to work as a DBA or I can work on myself and my trading. I chose to work on myself and my trading,” Reynaldo said, adding that it was the best decision he had made that turned his trading career around.

As a tae-kwondo champion, Reynaldo said his training as an athlete – which requires focus and steely determination, helped him in harnessing his skills and psychology when it comes to trading.

 

“For about six months I worked on myself and my psychology and tried to understand myself better. Within a span of three to four months I’ve turned profitable again,” Reynaldo said.

He added, “Everyone has their own trading system, but I believe successful trading is about 99 per cent psychology and 1 per cent system. Everyone can learn how to build and design a system, but no one but yourself can teach you your own psychology when it comes to dealing with the markets.”

Today Reynaldo applies the powerful combination of his profitable system and psychology as he deals with the market everyday. He classifies himself as a swing trader and holds position for an average of two to three days.

 
  12
<< top
next>>  
  frader in action >> reynaldo  

 

 


 



“I usually have a short list of potential trades, say about 10 positions that I will look at, then I will choose two or three out of the 10,” Reynaldo said.

Some of his outstanding wins include a 7000 per cent increase in his trading capital in four months. There was also a nine month period where he increased his trading capital by 500 per cent.

He trades mostly CFDs these days with the majority in Australian and US share CFDs. Foreign exchange and index trading make up about 20 per cent of his trades.

With more than five years of trading under his belt and an impressive success rate, Reynaldo said one of his ongoing challenges is to stay “focused and not to become egotistical amidst his winnings.”

“Sometimes it is easy to get the feeling that you have to be successful and profitable with all your trades. You want all your trades to be winners. You don’t want to think or accept that some trades can go wrong. But for me, I’d rather be a profitable trader than sticking to a trade that’s gone wrong,” Reynaldo said.

 


 



 
  13
<< top
next>>  
  from the dealing desk >> phil martin  

 

 

 

I

The song remained very much the same for the market in the month that was, resulting in a reasonably restrictive trading range. It was interesting to see though some quite bullish signs of life from the market in the tail end which may suggest some degree of resumption of the stronger part of the bull trend we have seen before the temporary volatility set in a few months ago.

As I write this, the S&P/ASX 200 has managed to push through the 5,150 point mark for the first time since it was last repulsed at this point back in July 2006.

 

 

Some people may see this as an important factor though it is worth noting that the index is still trading well adrift of the record highs seen back in May 2006. In every likelihood, there is probably a good chance that we may continue to see a degree of range trading in the market overall. I think that quite a bit of the exuberance that existed some months ago will have been damaged until the index can more consistently reassert itself.

 
  14
<< top
next>>  
  from the dealing desk >> phil martin  

 

 


In recent times there have been sporadic surges in the market’s value overall and with that in mind, we have seen quite an aggressive selling response. It is possible to account for this as a case of the jitters from some traders who want to quickly lock in small profits rather than hold on for a better performance in a trending market.

Importantly for the overall sentiment of the market there has been quite a resumption of strength from the finance sector which is one of the key areas that really needs to perform to push the index higher. One of the things that is worth bearing in mind is that the big miners and the big finance companies dominate the index so movements one way or the other really need to be supported by these larger companies. It is worth not losing sight of how these things work.

Some of the tight range trading seen in the last month created a great deal of frustration amongst traders. When the market is traveling comfortably and consistently in one direction or the other it certainly does make trading an ‘easier’ way to make a living. Outside of these times it means that trend trading strategies can become less effective than they are when the market is moving consistently.


 


One of the areas to look out for in the coming month is the energy sector which is facing an interesting time. The volatility being seen in this area is probably responding to the choppy nature of the oil price at the moment. Currently US Crude Oil is trading a little below the US$69 a barrel mark. In recent months we haven’t seen the price of oil remain below the US$70 mark for any length of time before being pushed higher once more.

The reason this is quite an interesting position for traders is because of the enormous number of unforeseen factors that can move the oil price, but as I suggested, it will be a little tricky to predict. Simmering geopolitical tensions aside awareness of the impact that further serious hurricanes could have on production in the Gulf of Mexico should not be underestimated. Despite the fact that this hurricane season has thus far been quite moderate, this is a factor that could certainly change and will have an immediate effect on the price of oil should further damage occur to operations within the region.

Interestingly, we have seen many of the petroleum companies greatly benefit from the higher price of oil, there have been companies around the region completely blindsided by the higher price with the some of the most notable being the airlines. Naturally enough, pressure on the airlines has been a global phenomenon and not simply limited to Australia.


 


In a fashion quite similar to our overall equity market, it may seem unlikely that we will see a consistent move downward in the oil price. Indeed, over time it can find a more steady direction but there will be an ever present concern in the immediate future that supply levels may be threatened from any number of different sources which of course can have quite an immediate and dramatic effect.



 
  15
<< top
next>>  
  Q & A >>  

 

 


readers are invited to ask dave questions about trading strategies. write to dave at d.land@cmcmarkets.com

Can you tell me which is better – mechanical or discretionary trading? Discussions I have had don’t seem to yield much balance.
Nicholas, Perth

This is one question that I can give you a little bit of personal experience on how the argument can polarize traders. Once when discussing the issue at a seminar I received quite an aggressive dressing down from a person who said that it was impossible to make money using a discretionary method. When I argued that this was not essentially the case, I was told to produce statistics to prove my argument. And herein lies the real crux of difference between the two.

A mechanical system requires you to have a series of signals that tell you what to buy, how much to buy, where to place your stops, and when to sell. The way in which this type of system is developed comes from ‘backtesting’ where you test your system on historic data with the plan of extrapolating the results into the future. The backtesting essentially develops for the trader a statistical probability that any given trade will be successful. Part of it also hinges on the trades requiring no input from the trader themselves once the system has been devised. It tells you to buy – you buy.

The discretionary system allows you to make alterations to those factors I described in the previous paragraph. Buy; don’t buy. Sell; don’t sell.

 

Dear Dave

Here’s the thing though. Many of the best traders I know fall into the category of discretionary traders but in many ways, when you watch the way in which they operate, you can see quite a part of them that is almost mechanical. By this, I mean that they have a very clear picture in mind in terms of what they are looking for when they are determining what things to buy or sell.

This type of behaviour would suggest to me that these are people who have been trading for such a long time that they know what works and what doesn’t and they trade according to what experience tells them to do which in one way means that they are acting on their own inbuilt ‘mechanical system’. In some ways you could almost short cut this experience element through backtesting which would allow you to let your computer tell you what works and what doesn’t.

 

So does this mean that system trading takes out the fuss and boils everything down to a simple set of rules? Perhaps – but it isn’t without its own particular type of discipline.

The one drawback that I see of system trading is that it requires complete trust in the system that you are using. Remember – buy when it says buy. Sell when it says sell. This is really easy in principle but much harder to practically apply when money is on the line. The system requires you to take every trade to be successful – but what happens if you have taken 8 or 9 losing trades in a row. All of a sudden a system may seem a lot more difficult to stomach.

So where does this leave us at the end of the day? I think it will be difficult for any individual to simply pick up and run with the methods of any other person.

 
  16
<< top
next>>  
  profit vs. trading volume >>  



Australia’s second largest gold mining company Oxiana (OXR) posted a record profit as metal prices soared, making it the most profitable stock for traders who held long positions.

Another miner to benefit from stronger metal prices was BHP Billiton, which announced a record US$10b profit. BHP Billiton Plc (UK) performed well on the back of the profit announcement, making BLT (UK) the most profitable international stock for long position holders. It was also the most traded international stock.

The positive BHP Billiton report also created interest on the local market, making BHP the most heavily traded stock in August.

On the back of the BHP and OXR news, good results from other mining companies like Zinifex (ZFX) and Jubilee Mining (JBM) created a lot of interest in the AUSMATERIAL sector which saw plenty of trading volume for the month, making it the most actively traded sector and the most profitable sector for traders.

A similar trend occurred amongst Global sectors with UKMINING seeing an upturn in trading numbers on higher metals prices. Continued volatility in energy prices, particularly in US Crude Oil, saw short term sector positions in USOIL/GAS produce good results.

 

 

   
  17
<< top
   
The content of this website does not constitute a recommendation nor does it take into account your investment objectives, financial situation nor particular needs. CMC Markets recommends you seek independent advice. Before acquiring any of CMC Markets’ products, you should obtain and consider the Financial Services Guide available at our website www.cmcmarkets.com.au/education. CMC Markets is the trading name of CMC Markets Pty Ltd (ACN 100 058 106) (AFS Licence 279437).